Shabbat Cholent (Hamin) with Brown Eggs

Cholent (hamin) with beef, beans, wheat berries, potatoes and brown eggs. Soak overnight, work 30 minutes on Friday, and it cooks until Shabbat lunch.

Total time
32 hr
Hands-on
30 min
Difficulty
Easy
Makes
8 servings
One serving
about 500 g
Protein per 100 g
8 gabout 41 g a serving
Meat
Meat
Cholent in a pot with beef, potatoes, beans, wheat berries and brown hamin eggsIllustrative image

NoyGrandma, my cholent came out dry and stuck to the bottom. What did I do wrong?

Grandma EstherYou were stingy with the water, sweetheart. Cholent drinks all night, so you give it enough right from the start.

Instructions

Cook mode: keep screen on
  1. The night before, cover the beans and wheat berries with plenty of water in a large bowl and soak for about 12 hours. The next day, drain and rinse them.

  2. Heat the oil in a large, heavy pot with a lid that can go on a hot plate or into the oven. Sear the beef in two batches, on each side, until browned, and move it to a plate.

  3. In the same pot, fry the onions for over medium heat, until golden brown. Add the garlic, tomato paste, paprika, cumin and turmeric and stir for .

  4. Return the beef to the pot and scatter the beans and wheat berries around it. Arrange the whole potatoes on top, drizzle with the date syrup and season with the salt and pepper.

  5. Rinse the eggs and gently tuck them in between the potatoes. Pour in boiling water until everything is covered by about 2 cm (1 in).

  6. Bring to a boil, cover and cook over low heat for about 1½ hours. Check halfway that there is enough water, and add boiling water if needed.

  7. Before Shabbat begins, move the covered pot to the Shabbat hot plate (plata), or into an oven heated to 100°C (210°F). You can also move the cholent into a slow cooker set to LOW. It stays hot and covered all night, for at least 10 hours and until Shabbat lunch.

  8. Serve hot, straight from the pot. Peel the eggs and give everyone a piece of beef, some beans and wheat berries, a potato and a brown egg. The beef is done when it falls apart easily with a fork.

Grandma’s tip

Don't throw away the dry brown onion skins. Tuck them into the pot along with the eggs, and they turn the eggs a deep brown, the way it was done in the old days. Take them out before serving.

Noy’s shortcut

Within two hours of lunch, divide the leftovers into single-serving containers, without the eggs, and freeze them. On a weeknight, heat one in the microwave until it steams, and there is a winter dinner.

Variations

  • Moroccan hamin: swap the beans for chickpeas, and add a sweet potato cut into large chunks, 4-5 dates and a pinch of cinnamon. You can cook the wheat berries in a cooking bag and serve them separately.
  • Ashkenazi cholent: use pearl barley instead of the wheat berries and add another ½ cup of beans.
  • Chicken cholent: replace the beef with 1200 g (2.5 lb) of bone-in chicken thighs or drumsticks, which don’t dry out in the long cooking.
  • Vegetarian cholent: leave out the beef, and add another cup of chickpeas or beans and 2 more tablespoons of oil. The cholent is then parve.
  • Without beans or without wheat: replace the beans with more wheat berries and a sweet potato, or the wheat berries with more beans.

Storing

Cool the leftovers and refrigerate them within two hours of serving. Cholent keeps in the fridge for 3-4 days and in the freezer for up to 3 months, without the eggs. Reheat it in a pot over low heat with a little water, until it steams and bubbles.

Questions people ask

How long do you cook cholent?

About 1½ hours on the stove, then at least 10 hours on a Shabbat hot plate, in a 100-110°C (210-230°F) oven or in a slow cooker on LOW. Most people move it there on Friday afternoon and serve it at Shabbat lunch, so it cooks for 16-20 hours in all. That is what gives it its brown color and deep flavor.

How do I make cholent in a slow cooker?

Make the cholent in a regular pot following the recipe, including the boil and the cooking on the stove. Then move it into the slow cooker, cover and set it to LOW until lunch. The boil at the start matters, because beans need a good boil before long cooking at low heat.

Can I make cholent without soaking the beans?

Yes. In the morning, boil the beans and wheat berries in water for 2 minutes, turn off the heat and leave them in the hot water for an hour. Then continue as usual. You can also add them dry with 2 more cups of water, but they may come out less soft and even.

How do I make cholent eggs (huevos haminados)?

Rinse fresh eggs and put them whole, in their shells, into the cholent pot. Overnight the shells turn brown and the whites turn beige and creamy. Peel them just before serving.

What is the difference between cholent and hamin?

They are the same Shabbat stew under two names. Cholent is the Ashkenazi name, and that version often has barley and beans. Hamin, from the Hebrew word for hot, is the Sephardic and Israeli name, and the Moroccan version (dafina or skhina) often has chickpeas, wheat berries, sweet potato and eggs.

How long does cholent keep in the fridge?

3-4 days in an airtight container. Cool it and refrigerate it within two hours of serving, and reheat it until it steams and bubbles.